Sleep Duration Is a Key Factor in Predicting On-Duty Alertness

Matthew van Wollen

By Matthew van Wollen
Chief Financial Officer, Pulsar Informatics, Inc.

Posted on September 5, 2023
Stressed female pilot sitting at the airport.

After a poor night of sleep, it is common to feel tired, sluggish and even irritable. More important for air operators, poor sleep is also associated with increased fatigue—which can directly impact employee performance and put lives at risk.

New research just published in the journal Sleep Advances quantifies how much-reduced sleep translates into increased risk.

An Important Study on Sleep and Fatigue

The research was conducted by Pulsar Informatics in coordination with a customer performing air medical transport operations. It used the Psychomotor Vigilance Test (PVT) to objectively assess fatigue-related changes to alertness resulting from inadequate sleep, extended wakefulness and other issues that impact both sleep quality and quantity.

PVT measures an individual’s reaction time to stimuli that occur at random intervals and therefore is an excellent measure of vigilant attention. Obtaining a high score on the PVT (commonly known as failing the test) is associated with impaired alertness. The elevated risk threshold is a PVT score of 12, which corresponds to 12 errors during the test. An error occurs either as a false start (premature response) or a lapse (response time of longer than 355 milliseconds).

Originally, the PVT was conceived as a 10-minute test, which is too long to be deployed in operational settings. Thankfully, previous research has shown that a brief, 3-minute version of PVT is sensitive in detecting fatigue. It is the 3-minute version that was used in the research study.

The research confirmed that the PVT can identify situations where fatigue is an operational risk hazard. This finding is highly relevant for charter and business aviation organizations seeking to quantify pilot fatigue and manage this risk in their operations.

The study also found that the amount of sleep obtained during the previous night is a key factor in predicting alertness on duty. While the link between sleep and performance is unsurprising, this research now provides a quantitative framework for understanding the relationship between them.

A 10x Increase in PVT Failure Due to Fatigue

The incidence rate of failing the PVT after obtaining between 7 and 9 hours of sleep the night before without any other risk factors present is approximately 1 in 1,000. This means 0.1% of people in a sample population will exhibit impaired alertness after a good night’s sleep.

However, this assumes full adherence to the PVT testing protocol—focusing and making a full effort when taking the test. Even if an individual is not experiencing fatigue, the testing environment can lead to increased failure rates. For example, external stimuli such as a noisy environment, interruptions, visual distractions and other disruptions often increase the failure rate of the test.

Even so, fatigue is the primary reason behind high PVT scores, with known fatigue risk factors including a strenuous work schedule, insufficient sleep and a high workload. When such risk factors are present, the rate of failing the PVT increases to a range of 1 to 2%. That is more than 10 times the baseline rate.

Alertness Measurement Is Essential

For air operators seeking a comprehensive approach to fatigue risk management, alertness measurement is a central component. Pulsar Informatics worked closely with Dr. David Dinges, the sleep researcher who created and validated the PVT, to refine the technology over a period of 10 years and deploy it to NASA and the DOD Special Forces.

Today, Pulsar Informatics has adapted the PVT for various technology platforms. It is the gold standard in validating and screening for alertness deficits.

Contact us to learn more about how we can help your organization develop and implement a comprehensive fatigue risk management program using PVT technology.

Pulsar Informatics, Inc. Pulsar Informatics, Inc.
Pulsar Informatics is an IS-BAO I3SA certified company specializing in systems that help organizations reduce fatigue-related risk and achieve peak performance. Fleet Insight enables safety managers and schedulers to proactively evaluate fatigue across their entire operation’s schedule and formulate mitigation strategies. Fatigue Meter Pro Planner is used by pilots, flight attendants, and maintenance personnel to evaluate their individual flight and duty schedule.

© 2024 Pulsar Informatics, Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

Related Posts

frustrated mom with daughter on cellphone in background

More Than a Box Tick: Achieving Operational Flexibility With an FRMS

Moms know best. This adage holds true in many domains of family life—allergies, grades, crushes. When thinking about aviation safety, though, perhaps the best illustration drawn from mom’s expertise is…

Posted on July 8, 2024
Woman signaling the pilot with marshalling wands at airport

The Effects of a Learning Mindset on Safety Culture

As aviation departments strive to enhance their safety performance, a critical yet often overlooked element is the need to foster a learning-culture mindset. This mindset shift can unlock invaluable opportunities for continuous improvement, employee engagement and creating a resilient safety environment. From a behavioral management perspective, as your company’s learning culture goes, so goes the ongoing success of your SMS.

Posted on July 8, 2024